top of page

Notice to Readers — How We Are Testing McLean Lake Landowner Losses

Writer: John T
John T
11 minutes ago
2 min read

Notice to Readers • Enquiry and research only. This notice explains how we are testing whether specific land-use restrictions imposed by Council caused a loss in value or added expense at McLean Lake. The actual loss remains unverified.

What we are trying to establish

The enquiry is limited to losses the evidence links to the specific Council restrictions under review. Dated maps, By-law 874/81 and written planning records help identify which uses were available and which remained. The four-lot ridge concept is a planning and valuation question to test.

John Tait has approached AACI appraisers and prepared an itemized ledger and specimen valuation. The ledger records each potential loss, its calculation and the evidence needed. Expenses require invoices, payment records and any credits. A tax difference needs a supported baseline for each year.

How the property would be valued

An independent AACI appraiser would compare the whole parcel on the same valuation date. Tier A reflects the verified restrictions. Tier B assumes the specific restrictions under enquiry are absent and retains all other applicable controls. The appraiser would first establish what use would realistically be available under each scenario.

Potential sales evidence includes closed MLS transactions, Teranet GeoWarehouse sales history and transfers recorded through Ontario’s OnLand registry. Severn’s planning records help verify each comparable’s permitted uses. Sales inside the mapped area can inform both tiers if they show a verified difference in use, such as a feasible dwelling site, and are otherwise comparable.

If close sales are scarce, the appraiser can consider older sales or comparable rural markets with supported adjustments. A cash-flow method may be appropriate where market-supported inputs are available. If the evidence supports only the restricted value, the other value and any percentage loss remain pending.

The proposed 50-sale study and simple mean

The research target is 50 verified sales, 25 per tier, for up to 25 matched pairs. Match on access, usable acreage, terrain, waterfront, servicing and sale date. Document adjustments and exclusions, then report the usable pair count, median and range alongside the mean.

Pair percentage = (adjusted Tier B price − adjusted Tier A price) ÷ adjusted Tier B price × 100. Use a positive Tier B price. Final mean percentage = sum of usable pair percentages ÷ number of usable pairs. Include zero and negative results.

Indicative property loss = independently supported Tier B value × final mean percentage ÷ 100, if the appraiser finds the sample fits McLean Lake. If the appraiser can support both values directly, subtract Tier A from Tier B and use the study mean as a cross-check.

Illustration only • Pair results of 10%, 20% and 30% average to 20%. Applied to a hypothetical Tier B value of $520,000, that gives $104,000. These figures are fictional. The study mean and actual loss remain pending.

Authorities and planning records

 
 
bottom of page